The Hagstrom Report

Agriculture News As It Happens

Navigation

Kass expects school meal challenges in lame duck session, comments on antibiotics efforts

2014_1028_BlackPollanKass White House nutrition adviser Sam Kass, right, makes a point during a discussion at the James Beard Conference in New York City today. At left is journalist Jane Black, who lead the discussion, and in center is Michael Pollan, food writer and University of California at Berkeley professor. (Jerry Hagstrom/The Hagstrom Report)


NEW YORK CITY — The Obama administration expects Congress to consider pulling back on some of the healthier meals regulations in the school lunch and breakfast programs if it passes an omnibus appropriations bill in the lame duck session, Sam Kass, the White House nutrition adviser and executive director of First Lady Michelle Obama’s Let’s Move program, said today at the James Beard Conference here.

Asked by a conference attendee for the administration’s goals next year in the reauthorization of the child nutrition programs, Kass said that the first goal is “just preventing all the success from being rolled back. We will see more efforts in the lame duck session. We need to be very diligent in putting on the pressure.”

Kass noted that as a White House official he cannot tell people to lobby, but he told the conference attendees, “Pressure works. People on the Hill don’t like people calling them. Engaged citizens have an impact. People’s voices need to be clear. Write op-eds, make sure the school nutrition directors know what you want and need.”

Kass did not say what he expects Congress to do, but the House version of the fiscal year 2015 Agriculture appropriations bill contains a provision that would allow schools whose officials say they have lost money on the school lunch program for six months to go back to rules before the 2010 Healthy Hunger-Free Kids Act was implemented.

The Senate bill contains a softer provision.

Although neither the full House nor the Senate has passed an Agriculture appropriations bill, appropriators are expected to work on an omnibus bill that would incorporate provisions from the bills that have been considered by the Agriculture appropriations subcommittees.

Advocates for the healthier meals rules hope to keep the Senate version of the school meals section, but one issue of particular interest is whether there is an attempt to roll back the requirement that each student take a half-cup of fruits or vegetables at each meal.

The School Nutrition Association has proposed giving students the option of taking the fruit or vegetable.

Kass made his comments at a session in which he and food writer Michael Pollan, the University of California at Berkeley professor who wrote “The Omnivore’s Dilemma,” were interviewed by journalist Jane Black.

Pollan asked Kass what the food movement could do to be more effective, and Kass replied that the movement should “consolidate around a few asks.”

“There is no magic bullet but we would do better to analyze where the ripe fruit is,” he said. “There are some things we can do now and there are some things we can yell about but we aren’t going to be able to move the ball down the field.”

He also said that the movement “could be more effective about supporting progress when it is not perfect.”

When an individual, a school, or a business steps out and takes a risk “and they get lambasted because it did not go far enough, they won’t want to take a next step.”

Companies, Kass noted, are worried about their brands and want credit for their actions.

Kass told Pollan the administration deserved credit for getting rid of the direct payments that crop farmers got whether prices are high or low. Pollan said he would congratulate the administration on that, but noted that “editors won’t give us assignments to write those bouquets to the administration.”

Some food activists have criticized the Obama administration’s program urging antibiotics companies to voluntarily stop selling their products for animal growth promotion rather than therapeutic purposes.

But Kass said he “would argue that we have taken incredibly aggressive steps” that accomplished what activists wanted in the law.

Once the label on a drug is changed to state that it is to be used for therapeutic purposes rather than growth, the sale of that drug for growth promotion will be “a violation of the law,” he said, noting that rulemaking on the drugs would have been very time consuming.

Kass said it remains to be seen whether the voluntary program is effective, but said the administration is working hard to develop a process to obtain that data.

He also said activists should urge consumers not to buy and eat meat from animals that have been grown with antibiotics for growth promotion.

But one problem, Kass said, is antibiotic-free meat is more expensive and “people are not buying.” Activists, he said, need to find language “that makes this more compelling.”

But Pollan noted that the issue of antibiotics does not have the same emotional resonance with consumers that some other issues have because there are “several steps” between the use in animals and consumption.

Pollan suggested Kass should be promoted from nutrition policy adviser to food policy adviser so that federal policies in the Agriculture Department and the Environmental Protection Agency, for example, would not operate at cross-purposes.

Kass also said he believes the Obama administration can work with industry in some ways to reduce obesity while able to oppose the same industry at other times.

He said it would be impossible to reduce obesity without working with the companies from which most Americans get their food.

“The world is a messy place,” Kass said. “Sometimes you can work with someone and find common ground, other times you have to battle it out. My experience is the reality does not match the level of cynicism we have. “We don’t give ourselves enough credit for the incredible amount of change we’ve made in an incredibly short period of time.”